Quebec's Parliament Buildings:
Witness To History, Luc Noppen and Gaston Deschenes, Les Publications du
Québec, Montreal, 1986, 204 pp.
Who can visit parliament buildings
and not be impressed by the solemnity of the place, as though the rooms, the
walls, the corridors, even the chairs, breathed history? Some famous political
figure comes into your mind -- you imagine him strolling through the very halls
where you yourself are walking; in the chamber the guide points out his seat
and you hear his voice raised in debate. And the irreverence with which we
sometimes regard politicians is, for the moment, forgotten. The physical space
where the political history of a nation has been made has a definite symbolic
dimension; this makes such sites, both for their own citizens and for tourists,
centres of pilgrimage, political Pantheons. The architecture and ornamentation
of parliament buildings illustrate the spirit of their people. This reviewer
has had the privilege of visiting a good many legislatures, in Canada (the
federal Parliament and the legislative assemblies in Quebec City, Toronto,
Fredericton and Winnipeg), in Europe (the French National Assembly and Senate,
the headquarters of the Belgian Conseil de la Communauté-française) and in
Africa (Senegal, Mali, Ivory Coast, Cameroon); and more than any other national
monument, parliament buildings are the concrete and visible symbol of a community.
Because of this they are designed,
built, decorated, adapted, and preserved from the ravages of time by the best
architects, artists and master craftsmen their society has to offer. They are
part of the national heritage, perhaps even its crowning glory.
We are, however, not always so
familiar with the histories of the buildings. As far as Quebec's National
Assembly is concerned, this gap in our knowledge has now been filled by Quebec's
Parliament Buildings: Witness to History, a new book by architectural
historian Luc Noppen and historian Gaston Descháˆánes. Published to mark the
150th anniversary of the birth of Eugène-Etienne Taché , the architect who
designed the National Assembly, the book succeeds admirably in weaving together
the strands of the construction and evolution of the buildings, and the
development of parliamentary government in Quebec. From it we learn that the
construction one hundred years ago coincided with the consolidation of
parliamentary government in Quebec: the overlapping of the executive and
legislative functions that characterized parliamentary life after Confederation
was reflected in the fact that one building housed both government and
parliament. We also learn, coming closer to our own time, that the extensive
parliamentary reform sparked by the Quiet Revolution coincided with a major
rethinking and modernisation of the National Assembly buildings (which are
obviously Quebec's most important historical site). The chapters devoted to
architecture and ornamentation are especially interesting. An architectural
whole unique in North America, Quebec's parliament buildings adopt with
sobriety, practicality and economy of means a variety of trends in French
architecture, mainly the Second Empire style of the last half of the XIXth
century. The only discordant note is the central tower, which, the authors
suggest, may have been inspired by the Middle Ages, but which may also simply
have been influenced by the architects. Statues, emblems, coats of arms,
frescoes, all suggest Quebec's motto, "Je me souviens" [I remember],
although there are some extraordinary lapses in that memory: a statue of
Jacques Cartier was never part of the statuary planned for the façade because
the discoverer of Canada had fallen into political disgrace.
Ten years of university research
covering two centuries of Quebec's political history are synthesised into an
essay on parliamentary life that discusses the evolution of parliamentary
structures, elections, parliamentarians, the rules of parliamentary procedure,
and the working conditions of an MNA. This alone would make the book a unique
and indispensable reference tool.
It is also a feast for the eye,
amply and strikingly illustrated, as fascinating to skim as to study -- an
invaluable complement to a visit to the National Assembly. It will appeal to
the lover of history and anecdote, the art enthusiast and the collector of
beautiful books. We must hope it is the first of many more in other
legislatures.
Serge Pelletier, Association of French Speaking Parliamentarians